Hindenburg Research – Adani Group Row

January 3, 2024

In January 2023, US-based short seller Hindenburg Research published a report alleging several improper dealings by Indian conglomerate Adani Group headed by Gautam Adani. The report accused the group of stock manipulation, use of offshore shell companies, and raising debt through public banks to fund unprofitable capital spending among other things. This sparked a massive sell-off of Adani group stocks resulting in the loss of over Rs 4 lakh crore in market value over two days.

Adani Group Refutes Claims

Adani Group responded with a 413-page rebuttal dismissing the Hindenburg report as baseless and unethical. The group claimed that Hindenburg had only presented selective information to paint a misleading picture. However, Hindenburg asserted that its report was just the “tip of the iceberg” and that it possessed more damaging evidence that was not disclosed.

The Issue Reaches the Apex Court

In February 2023, a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) was filed in the Supreme Court seeking an SIT probe into Hindenburg’s allegations against the Adani group. Over the next months, the court asked SEBI to investigate the charges and also set up a panel to evaluate mechanisms for investor protection.

In November, after reserving its verdict on the pleas, the Supreme Court finally pronounced its judgment in January 2024.

SC Verdict Brings Relief to Adani Group

The Supreme Court bench headed by Chief Justice DY Chandrachud rejected the plea for an SIT probe into the Adani issue. It ruled that there were no grounds to transfer the investigation from SEBI to a special team. The court ordered SEBI to complete probes into two remaining cases related to the allegations within three months.

The bench dismissed the OCCRP report critical of SEBI presented by the petitioners as insufficient proof to doubt the regulator’s actions. It stated reliance on third-party reports without verification cannot be accepted.

What it Means for the Adani Group

The Supreme Court judgment has brought major relief to the Adani Group which has maintained its innocence amidst the controversy. With the court finding no issues in SEBI’s handling of the probes so far, the regulator’s decisions in the two pending cases will be crucial for the conglomerate.

If no major adverse findings are discovered by SEBI, it will aid in restoring some lost confidence of investors and help stabilize Adani’s fortunes after the steep drop in market value.

Impact on Investor Protection

While the court found no gaping holes in the regulatory system, it ordered the government and SEBI to still investigate if any strengthening of investor protection norms are needed. This includes evaluating if Hindenburg flouted any rules.

The committee appointed by the SC had already submitted that existing mechanisms for investors were adequate during turmoil. However, implementation of its recommendations will improve transparency and disclosure requirements for companies.

Current Status

The Adani-Hindenburg saga has been one of the most explosive corporate battles in Indian history. While Adani has scored a court victory for now, Hindenburg claims to possess more evidence up its sleeve. Much will depend on what SEBI concludes in its remaining investigations.

But improved investor protection norms and stable markets will be the ultimate winners in the long run due to the spotlight shone by the adversary firms. The case will hold key learnings for Indian regulators and corporates even as tensions cool temporarily.

« Previous Post Next Post »